According to our product testers ‘ responses, we selected Honest Baby Fitted Crib Sheets as the best crib sheets due to their reasonable price, stylish design, and high quality.
A safe place for a baby to sleep may feel empty. Bumpers, blankets, pillows, quilts, and stuffed animals should not be in the crib. Furthermore, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) says that your child should only sleep on a crib sheet, which should fit snugly to avoid any open fabric. With only one safe piece of furniture to use, it’s simple to see why parents and parents-to-be make it a point to find the best crib sheets.
I have four kids, one of whom is a year old, and I’ve bought a lot of crib sheets in the last ten years. I know how challenging it can be to choose the right baby furniture for your family from all the options that are out there. So, I tried out the best baby crib sheets on the market myself. We put all the items that made it to the final round through rigorous testing, including testing them while my youngest child slept and napped for several days.
Testing has shown that you do not have to choose between a set that is fashionable or one that is comfortable; you can have both of these things at the same time. Here are the best baby crib sheets that are stylish, soft, and made of materials that are safe for babies. While exploring crib sheets, you might also like top-rated best cribs, travel cribs for babies, and crib mattresses.
Our Favorite Crib Sheet
- Best Overall: HonestBaby Fitted Crib Sheets
- Cute Crib Sheets: Rookie Humans 100% Cotton Sateen Fitted Crib Sheet
- Best for Baby Shower Gift: Premium Knit Baby Crib Sheets by Copper Pearl
- Best Waterproof: Ely’s & Co. Patent Pending Waterproof Crib Sheet
- Best Breathable Crib Sheets: Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheets
- Best Budget-Friendly: KeaBabies 2Pack Organic Crib Sheets
- Softest Crib Sheets: Pobi Baby 2-Pack Fitted Crib Sheets
- Best Crib Sheets for Sensitive Skin: Burt Bees Baby Solid Fitted Crib Sheet
- Best All-In-One: Blissful Diary Muslin Crib Sheets
- Best Extra Soft: Mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet
1. Best Overall Crib Sheets: HonestBaby Fitted Crib Sheets
For a cozy nursery that is also environmentally conscious, look no further than these crib sheets. Their soft, breathable surface is perfect for every season, and they are made from 100% organic cotton certified by GOTS. The jersey fabric is machine washable and guarantees all-day comfort for sensitive skin. This set of sheets has an extra stretchy, all-around-inch surround-inch quality elastic that will provide a tight fit on any standard crib or toddler bed mattress (28 inch x 52 inch). The sturdy build keeps its form and feel even after several washes, so it might survive through more than one kid.
The inherent moisture-wicking characteristics of cotton provide some protection from small spills, although they do not make the fabric waterproof. They require little maintenance since they are machine washable and stain-resistant. During revisions, you may easily remove and replace the fitted design. Their eco-friendly production procedures demonstrate Honest Baby’s dedication to sustainability. Honest Baby manufactures the sheets in factories that use safer chemicals and prioritize the well-being of their workers, utilizing resources obtained ethically. This set of sheets is perfect for the nursery. It comes in a variety of colors and designs to match all of the other necessities. They are a great buy because they are long-lasting, eco-friendly, and of high quality.
Pros
Cons
2. Cute Crib Sheets: Rookie Humans 100% Cotton Sateen Fitted Crib Sheet
The Rookie Humans Enchanted Meadow crib sheet awaits your little one’s resting quarters, offering a delightful fantasy. Made of 100% cotton sateen with a high thread count (230), this sheet is ideal for your young, sensitive skin. It has a tight, fitting design for safety and comfort, and it fits standard US crib mattresses (28″ x 52″ x 8″). The sheet’s most notable attribute is its premium printing process, which produces vivid, hand-painted features that maintain their sharpness and color vibrancy even after several washings. The whimsical meadow pattern will add a magical element to your nursery décor while also providing the ideal setting for priceless newborn pictures.
Thanks to its OEKO TEX certification, this sheet is safe for parents concerned about their children’s exposure to chemicals. Notable outlets such as The Today Show, Project Nursery, and Forbes have recognized the high-quality building, which has also won accolades in the industry. Though it softens with washing, some have noted that the sheet is initially rigid despite its excellent quality and aesthetic appeal. Buyers on a tighter budget may want to look elsewhere since the higher price reflects the premium amenities.
Pros
Cons
3. Best for Baby Shower Gift: Premium Knit Baby Crib Sheets by Copper Pearl
Stylish and cozy, these Copper Pearl Premium Knit Baby Crib Sheets are ideal for your little one’s nursery. These sheets are a favorite among parents due to their long-lasting quality and luxuriously smooth rayon knit fabric. Babies will have a restful night’s sleep thanks to the material’s low weight and breathability. The fashionable Chipinch pattern is the most eye-catching aspect of this sheet. It brings a whimsical element to any nursery décor. The pattern adaptability makes creating a unified nursery aesthetic easy when combined with other Copper Pearl items. This sheet, with its high-quality elastic stitching across the whole edge, fits all standard infant mattresses. It ensures a tight, clean, contemporary fit for safety and comfort.
You can’t go wrong with these sheets as a practical and thoughtful present for a baby shower. Both first-time and seasoned parents will appreciate the high-quality package. Thanks to the sturdy structure, the sheets will retain their softness and color vibrancy wash after wash, guaranteeing long-lasting usage.
Pros
Cons
4. Best Waterproof: Ely’s & Co. Patent Pending Waterproof Crib Sheet
Ely & Co. waterproof crib sheets are an excellent choice for parents looking for a practical option that combines comfort and safety. Thanks to these two packs of sheets crafted from eco-friendly waterproof TPU lining and 100% combed jersey knit cotton, there is no more hunting for individual mattress protectors. These sheets have an elasticized, flexible fit that hugs the mattress snugly and securely, making them ideal for regular crib and toddler bed measurements (52 inch x 28 inch x 9 inch). The waterproof liner prevents water from seeping through the soft, breathable cotton, making it an ideal sleeping surface. The Misty Blue option is fashionable for any nursery, thanks to its stripes and splash design. You can machine wash these sheets and dry them in a low-heat dryer, which simplifies their maintenance.
Pros
Cons
5. Best Breathable Crib Sheets: Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheets
For a safe and comfortable sleep environment for your little one, look no further than Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheets. Organic cotton muslin, which is delicate and comfortable for your little one, makes these very breathable sheets. The muslin fabric allows more air to circulate, making it perfect for those hot summer nights when paired with one of Newton’s breathable mattresses. These sheets, designed to fit a regular crib mattress (52 inches by 28 inches), feature an elasticized waist for a snug fit. The two sheets included in the kit allow you to easily swap them out as required. They are pre-shrunk and completely machine washable, so they are simple to care for and will last a long time.
These hypoallergenic sheets were created under stringent social and environmental standards, which led to their GOTS certification. Stylish and available in various patterns, such as Stardust Moonstone Mist, they are the perfect finishing touch for any baby nursery.
Pros
Cons
6. Best Budget-Friendly: KeaBabies 2Pack Organic Crib Sheets
The KeaBabies 2 Pack Organic Crib Sheets Woodland pattern is the ideal combination of eco-consciousness, style, and comfort for your little one’s nursery. These organic jersey cotton crib linens are perfect for your little one’s sensitive skin since they are soft and breathable. KeaBabies’ SnugFit Tech, a clever fabric weave, enhances these sheets, facilitating effortless fitting and removal. KeaBabies tailors these sheets to fit most crib mattresses, measuring 52 inches by 28 inches by 38 inches. The high-quality elastic band concealed inside the seams ensures a secure fit and long-lasting durability. The Woodland design is adorned with adorable woodland creatures, bringing a little bit of nature into your nursery. You may wash and dry these sheets without worrying about losing their plush texture or vivid color.
Pros
Cons
7. Softest Crib Sheets: Pobi Baby 2-Pack Fitted Crib Sheets
The 2-pack fitted crib sheets from Pobi Baby are the ideal combination of form and function for your baby room. High-quality cotton and spandex combine to create these sheets, making them gentle and breathable for your baby’s skin. Any nursery would benefit from the enchanting ‘Magical’ design, which depicts charming forest animals. With deep pockets and extra-thick elastic bands, these sheets are tailor-made to fit standard crib mattresses (52 inches by 28 inches) snugly and securely. Thanks to this innovation that prevents bunching, the sheet remains in position even when the sleeper is relatively active. Because they are machine washable and won’t shrink, wrinkle, or fade, these sheets need little upkeep. Their long-lasting quality ensures that they retain their suppleness and vivid hues even after several washes. Thanks to the two packs, you can be certain that you will never be without a fresh sheet.
Pros
Cons
8. Best Crib Sheets for Sensitive Skin: Burt Bees Baby Solid Fitted Crib Sheet
If you are looking for an organic, functional crib sheet for your baby, look no further than the Burt Bees Solid Fitted Crib Sheet. This sheet will be extra gentle on your baby’s skin since it is 100% organic cotton certified by GOTS. Combed and ring-spun cotton is more durable, softer, and less likely to pill when washed. For a safe, tight fit, sheets with the BeeSnug 360 design and quality elastic fit typical baby and toddler mattresses. As you lay your arms on the crib, you will feel the same familiar comfort of its jersey knit fabric, just as you would in a beloved t-shirt. These sheets are machine washable in cold water on a delicate cycle and come in various hues, including Cloud White. They are also very simple to maintain. Each wash preserves their color saturation and softens them. Organic cotton is hypoallergenic. Thus, these sheets are ideal for infants with skin sensitivities.
Pros
Cons
9. Best All-In-One: Blissful Diary Muslin Crib Sheets
Regarding your baby nursery, the Blissful Diary Muslin Crib Sheets blend elegance, functionality, and comfort. Your young one will sleep well on these two-pack sheets crafted from muslin cotton, a breathable and soft fabric. The dimensions of the typical crib mattress are 52 inches by 28 inches, and the sheets can fit mattresses up to 7 inches thick. These whimsical linens are perfect for any nursery, coming in various boho-inspired themes, including Roman Green and Leaf. The 360° elastic band ensures a tight and secure fit for your little one’s safety while they sleep. The sheets will retain their softness and brilliant colors even after several washings, thanks to the quality double-layer fabric structure that promotes longevity.
These sheets’ pre-shrunk technology and machine washability make them less likely to shrink than competing alternatives. For parents who are often on the go, this makes them an ideal option. With these two, you can easily switch up your sheets whenever needed.
Pros
Cons
10. Best Extra Soft: Mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet
For a crib sheet that combines design and comfort, choose the Mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet. This sheet is perfect for your little one’s sensitive skin since it is 100% cotton and has a 192-thread count. While keeping your little one warm and cozy, the pre-washed muslin fabric is very gentle and airy. The sheet has nine-inch-deep pockets and completely elasticized edges to provide a secure fit. The design accommodates typical crib mattresses measuring 28 inches by 52 inches. This style stays perfectly in place, even after washing, and is a breeze to take on and off. The sheet is an elegant addition to any nursery and is available in various hues, including Roman green.
Parents will appreciate how easy it is to clean this sheet, since it is machine washable. Because of its resilience, it can withstand several washings without losing its softness or color. With a 4.8-star rating, it has been highly praised by over 4,000 consumers for its high-quality construction, fit, and overall quality.
Pros
Cons
Test And Analysis of the Best Crib Sheets
In my search for the best crib sheets, I also looked at other qualities that parents care about:
Value
For a variety of reasons, the HonestBaby Fitted and Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheets are both excellent values. HonestBaby sheets are sturdy enough for numerous children due to their organic ingredients and eco-friendly construction. This durability explains their increased price. However, Newton Baby Linens’ two-pack of organic, breathable sheets is a terrific bargain for many climates and seasons.
For budget-conscious parents, choose the Ely & Co. waterproof crib sheets. As a sheet and mattress cover, it may save money. Affordably priced, the Blissful Diary Muslin features soft, breathable fabric and a handy two-pack.
Comfort
The Burt’s Bees and Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheets are comfortable. The Burt’s Bees sheet’s combed and ring-spun cotton softens with each wash, giving it a warm, familiar feel like a favorite t-shirt. Newton Baby linens, manufactured from organic muslin cotton, are soft and breathable, making them ideal for temperature adjustment in different climates.
The high thread count (230) makes the Rookie Humans 100% luxuriously comfortable, however some customers report early rigidity that relaxes. The Copper Pearl Premium Knit Baby Crib Sheets’ silky rayon knit fabric makes them lightweight and breathable.
Quality
The Mushie Extra Soft and Rookie Humans 100% are top-notch. The mushie sheet’s 192 thread count and pre-washed muslin fabric have won over thousands of customers for their comfort and quality. After several washes, premium printing preserves brilliant colors and precise graphics on the Rookie Humans sheet.
With their GOTS accreditation and durable construction, HonestBaby is high-quality. SnugFit Tech makes the KeaBabies 2 Pack Organic Crib Sheets simple to fit and remove, while preserving quality and longevity.
Durability
The Burt’s Bees and Newton Baby Crib Sheets are durable. The Burt’s Bees sheet contains combed and ring-spun cotton, which resists pilling and retains form after regular washing. Newton Baby linens, manufactured from organic muslin cotton, are sturdy and soften with each wash.
The HonestBaby Sheets retain their shape and feel after several washings. They are ideal for parents with many children. Copper Pearl sheets are known for their durability and color brilliance.
Materials
Newton Baby and HonestBaby Organic contain 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton, which is excellent. This guarantees high-quality organic textile manufacturing, making them ideal for parents concerned about chemical exposure and the environment.
High-quality cotton sateen gives the Rookie Humans 100% a smooth texture and luscious gloss. The Blissful Diary Muslin and Mushie Extra Soft contain muslin cotton, which is breathable and soft, making them excellent temperature regulators.
Waterproof
Ely & Co. is the top choice for waterproof features. The eco-friendly waterproof TPU liner and 100% combed jersey knit cotton make these sheets comfortable and spill-proof.
Most of the sheets, including HonestBaby and Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheets, are not waterproof. Because of cotton’s inherent capabilities, it may wick moisture, but not completely.
Easy to clean
Certain sheets stand out, but most are machine washable for simple cleaning. Ely & Co. Waterproof Crib Sheets are simple to clean thanks to their waterproof covering, which prevents liquids from penetrating. Low-heat machine washing and tumble drying are possible.
Machine washable and stain-resistant, HonestBaby Fitted Crib Sheets are simple to maintain. The Burt’s Bees and Mushie Extra Soft become softer with each wash without losing shape or color, making them practical and pleasant for long-term usage.
Eco-friendly
The HonestBaby and Newton Baby Crib Sheets are the most eco-friendly. Both use 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton, maintaining stringent environmental and social standards throughout manufacturing. In their manufacturing procedures, HonestBaby uses cleaner chemicals and promotes worker well-being.
Another eco-friendly alternative is the 100% organic cotton Burt’s Bees Baby Solid Fitted Crib Sheet. While not organic, Rookie Humans 100% is OEKO-TEX certified, making it eco-friendly.
Bottom Line
When looking for the best crib sheets, there are lots of cute and cozy choices. So, it might be challenging to figure out what’s best for the baby. You may be wondering, “How many crib sheets do I need?” Expectant parents should have a minimum of four fitted crib sheets available, despite the lack of a universally accepted solution. You can then have one soft baby sheet that fits snugly on the mattress, one in the washer, and two clean ones hidden away in the closet in case you need to change them all the time.
Deciding on a crib sheet style that suits your taste and the necessities of your nursery is the next challenging step. To ensure that the sheet fits snugly over your child’s mattress and doesn’t pop up over time, you should look for features like 360-degree fabric. Then, look through the fun illustrations, modern designs, and custom prints.
You should also make sure to study the care instructions for the crib sheet that you are interested in acquiring before making a purchase and maintain a realistic perspective regarding what will work best for your lifestyle. A crib sheet that requires a gentle cycle may not be the ideal choice if you’re looking for an item that you can throw in with your laundry.
